At 2nd Reward Issue, the newest castaways was s along with to stand of facing per other in one using one matches
In the a haphazard mark away from buffs, Natalie create remain on Hunahpu with Jeremy, Julie, and you will Reed Kelly. Jon, Keith, Kelley, and you will Missy Payne was in fact gone to live in Coyopa and you can was in fact replaced by the Alec Christy, Josh Canfield, and Wes. When proving the newbies the fresh Hunahpu go camping, Natalie showed that Hunahpu got very little grain remaining. Within Immune protection system Issue, Hunahpu effortlessly lost the fresh Coyopa group. The fresh new tribe following pleaded for lots more grain and you can was ready to call it quits one thing. A day later, Jeff Probst included rice however, got all luxuries Hunahpu compiled up until the period. Within Champion Duel, Reed won the fresh group an effective Survivor barbeque more Coyopa’s Baylor Wilson. Reed selected Julie to join Baylor to your Exile Isle. not, Natalie volunteered to visit exile having Baylor as an alternative. During exile, Baylor mutual the girl idea on the Invisible Defense mechanisms Idol having Natalie. Hunahpu won the latest Disease fighting capability Challenge, remaining Natalie safe from reduction.
On Date 16, the new tribes’ Forest Mail greatly created a merge. This was true in addition to people liked a tribe banquet. Because of their date into the Exile, Jeremy and Natalie had been with ease able to get Baylor and you may Missy to their side. Jeremy clashed which have Josh with each trying to get another voted away. But not, their strategy to avoid one other was delay because of age. From the 2nd Reward Problem, Natalie is teamed having Reed, Jeremy, Keith, and you may Wes and you may obtained a trip to an excellent Survivor taco bar. The fresh new castaways preferred new meal off tacos, however, no means are discussed since citizens were on different alliances. Within Defense mechanisms Problem, Jeremy won private immunity. Afterwards, at earliest Tribal Council following combine, Josh try chosen in a 6-5 vote.
Natalie’s group consisting of by herself, Jeremy, Wes, Reed, and you may Alec claimed the challenge
Natalie encountered off against Jaclyn twice and obtained each other rounds. However, Jeremy and you will Natalie offered the rewards so you’re able to Jon and Jaclyn in an effort to cement its alliance with them. After Baylor acquired immune protection system, new alliance designed to has a torn vote anywhere between Keith and Reed. However, on Tribal Council, Natalie try stunned whenever Jeremy is blindsided out from the game.
Just after Jeremy’s blindside, Natalie is actually enraged with Jon and you may desired revenge for her dropped comrade. At the 2nd Prize Challenge, Natalie are teamed which have Baylor, Missy, and you may Wes nonetheless they lost. Wes was delivered out to Exile, and you can Missy are permitted to embark on prize due to Reed providing his destination to this lady. Back during the go camping, Natalie wanted to find the fresh idol with Baylor. She delivered Reed and you may Keith off to pick firewood once the ladies manage score water. Natalie managed to efficiently find the idol, much to help you her and you may Baylor’s glee. From the Disease fighting capability Difficulties, they at some point emerged as a result of Natalie and Reed. Yet not, Natalie said in an effective confessional following challenge you to definitely she been watching superstars, and her eyes have been closure. Natalie realized that she wasn’t browsing past lengthier. Natalie bartered getting food and Jeff came back that have pizza pie, poultry wings, a great cookie, and you may a taller mug regarding h2o. Natalie wandered off and you may Reed acquired immune system. The program were to split the fresh vote ranging from Keith and you may Wes. But not, Reed envisioned you to definitely bundle and you will wanted to choose away Jon. From the Tribal Council, Keith believed to «proceed with the plan», and this alarmed others out-of Reed’s package. Until the ballots was basically realize, Natalie told Jon to relax and play his idol. Jon performed utilize the idol, and this motivated Keith 
to experience his. All the ballots up against one another men had been voided and Wes is actually eliminated.